• Health News,
  • Analysis,
  • Campaigns
  • SUPPORT US
  • Facebook
  • Twitter
The Lowdown The Lowdown
  • News
    Operose CEO moves to Number 10 advisor position
    April 1, 2021
    Bleak prospects for troubled ICSs
    March 21, 2021
    Sugar tax is a win-win  
    March 21, 2021
    Mega-lab not privatised insists Department
    March 20, 2021
    Frimley drops subco plan: Another one bites the dust
    March 20, 2021
    Campaigning for an All-Ireland National Health Service
    March 6, 2021
    Budget letdown: NHS faces record waiting lists and staff “exodus”
    March 4, 2021
    Mounting repairs threaten hospitals
    March 3, 2021
    Campaigners write to Hancock requesting investigation of Centene takeover of London GP surgeries
    February 25, 2021
    US company in takeover of network of GP practices
    February 4, 2021
    Previous Next
  • Topics
    1. NHS Long Term Plan
    2. Mental health
    3. Outsourcing
    4. Safety
    5. Private Providers
    6. Quality
    7. Hospitals
    8. Community healthcare
    9. View All
    Why are people objecting to CCG mergers?
    September 28, 2020
    Is Johnson pondering a NHS power grab?
    July 21, 2020
    No bold visions for Lancs and Cumbria ICS
    June 9, 2020
    As coronavirus highlights bed shortages, new SW London hospital plan could halve front line beds
    March 16, 2020
    Checklist or Wishlist
    February 20, 2020
    A question of trust – Colin Hutchinson, Doctors for the NHS
    February 17, 2020
    How seriously is the government committed to the long-term plan?
    January 20, 2020
    NHS England: five years of failure that have plunged NHS into growing chaos – comment
    November 28, 2019
    New plan urgently needed to cope with surge in mental health problems
    January 9, 2021
    Will NHS mental health care become more reliant on failing private companies?
    October 12, 2020
    Demand for mental health soars after patients abandoned in lockdown
    September 28, 2020
    CCGs caught short-changing mental health services
    July 22, 2020
    Mental health: still the poor relation?
    May 27, 2020
    Crisis continues in child mental health
    February 3, 2020
    Providers and Royal Colleges speak out as NHS performance falls to its worst ever level
    January 20, 2020
    Charity mental health provider misled CQC
    January 16, 2020
    White Paper: power grab, sea change or cementing in the status quo?
    February 9, 2021
    Hinchingbrooke staff celebrate as outsourcing plan dropped
    November 22, 2020
    North West Anglia NHS ‘bucking the trend’ towards safer hospital food, unions warn
    September 14, 2020
    Privatisation Protest at St Mary’s Hospital, Manchester
    July 21, 2020
    Expensive failures could cost lives
    July 7, 2020
    Homerton Hospital: trust board sticks with outsourcing giant
    July 7, 2020
    A “privatised” and “dysfunctional” system led to lack of PPE
    May 27, 2020
    NHS England’s deal a life-saver – even for private hospitals
    March 30, 2020
    Cumberlege inquiry: Patients are still being harmed by our healthcare system
    July 21, 2020
    CQC calls for intervention at failing trust
    July 21, 2020
    10 questions to ask about the NHS deal with the private hospitals
    June 23, 2020
    Unions draw up blueprint to enable NHS to return to more normal
    June 23, 2020
    Care homes and home care – the forgotten crisis
    April 15, 2020
    Too few midwives and too little funding continues to affect safe maternity care
    March 18, 2020
    Inquiry into chronic system failures at East Kent Trust
    February 17, 2020
    Safety warnings amid increase in “corridor nursing”
    February 3, 2020
    The History of Privatisation part 4: The early days of PFI
    March 29, 2021
    Private sector unfazed by White Paper
    March 6, 2021
    Campaigners write to Hancock requesting investigation of Centene takeover of London GP surgeries
    February 25, 2021
    Under cover of covid…
    February 21, 2021
    Private health and privatisation cost lives
    February 5, 2021
    NHS to take over six private hospitals at high cost
    January 22, 2021
    Private hospital group backs out of Covid deal to treat NHS patients
    January 6, 2021
    Private beds puzzle deepens
    October 26, 2020
    CQC calls for intervention at failing trust
    July 21, 2020
    10 questions to ask about the NHS deal with the private hospitals
    June 23, 2020
    Too few midwives and too little funding continues to affect safe maternity care
    March 18, 2020
    The History of Privatisation – first in a series of articles by John Lister
    March 2, 2020
    Health problems dog “red wall” areas
    February 17, 2020
    Inquiry into chronic system failures at East Kent Trust
    February 17, 2020
    Safety warnings amid increase in “corridor nursing”
    February 3, 2020
    Providers and Royal Colleges speak out as NHS performance falls to its worst ever level
    January 20, 2020
    Mounting repairs threaten hospitals
    March 3, 2021
    Vanishing front line beds pose threat to NHS future
    December 8, 2020
    Closed eyes to Covid reality – Leicester health chiefs push through flawed plan
    October 26, 2020
    The lives of people in Kent are in the hands of Matt Hancock
    October 26, 2020
    Phone ahead for A&E to avoid disappointment
    September 28, 2020
    NHS performance recovering, but record numbers are waiting
    September 28, 2020
    Impossible demands to step-up and redesign services
    September 14, 2020
    Puzzle of the private beds
    September 14, 2020
    Does government policy on shielding leave thousands exposed? 
    June 8, 2020
    Stay alert, control the eugenicists, save lives.
    May 12, 2020
    Care homes and home care – the forgotten crisis
    April 15, 2020
    The slow killing of the NHS by salami-slice
    March 16, 2020
    Roy Lilley: We should do like the Romans do
    March 16, 2020
    Health problems dog “red wall” areas
    February 17, 2020
    No evidence to back key policy on “frequent fliers”
    February 16, 2020
    Primary Care Networks: What’s the idea?
    February 3, 2020
    Waiting lists during the pandemic: from zero tolerance to looming crisis
    March 20, 2021
    How do GPs fit into the NHS?
    March 20, 2021
    The dying days of local NHS accountability
    March 20, 2021
    Campaigning for an All-Ireland National Health Service
    March 6, 2021
    White Paper: power grab, sea change or cementing in the status quo?
    February 9, 2021
    Why the US can easily afford universal health care
    January 22, 2021
    CCGs under pressure in NHS “integration” shakeup
    December 23, 2020
    MP proposes ‘reservist’ plan to bolster under-funded NHS
    December 9, 2020
    Previous Next
  • Analysis
    1. Comment
    2. Long read
    3. View All
    The dying days of local NHS accountability
    March 20, 2021
    Can campaigners unite over coming health Bill?
    March 6, 2021
    New NHS White Paper – the end of outsourcing?
    February 8, 2021
    Mental health services still waiting on promised improvements
    February 5, 2021
    Urgent changes needed to failing covid response
    January 25, 2021
    Private hospital group backs out of Covid deal to treat NHS patients
    January 6, 2021
    From pandemic to infodemic – NHS staff battle covid deniers, as well as the virus
    January 6, 2021
    Brexit deal limits damage to NHS, but where’s the benefit?
    January 6, 2021
    A History NHS privatisation, part 3
    February 21, 2021
    Why does NHS privatisation matter? 
    February 19, 2021
    Top NHS managers want post-Covid changes – but not much of it
    July 7, 2020
    The History of Privatisation – second in a series by John Lister
    March 16, 2020
    The slow killing of the NHS by salami-slice
    March 16, 2020
    Revealed: high cost of bullying in the NHS – Roger Kline
    March 2, 2020
    The History of Privatisation – first in a series of articles by John Lister
    March 2, 2020
    Checklist or Wishlist
    February 20, 2020
    The History of Privatisation part 4: The early days of PFI
    March 29, 2021
    Waiting lists during the pandemic: from zero tolerance to looming crisis
    March 20, 2021
    Private sector unfazed by White Paper
    March 6, 2021
    The great consultancy boom – from Covid to ICSs
    February 24, 2021
    Under cover of covid…
    February 21, 2021
    A History NHS privatisation, part 3
    February 21, 2021
    Why does NHS privatisation matter? 
    February 19, 2021
    White Paper: power grab, sea change or cementing in the status quo?
    February 9, 2021
    Previous Next
  • Explainers
    Billions are spent by the NHS on drugs every year, but how does it work?
    March 31, 2021
    LOWDOWN one-stop news roundup
    March 20, 2021
    How do GPs fit into the NHS?
    March 20, 2021
    Privatisation: Key facts
    February 20, 2021
    Covid contracts: the struggle for scrutiny 
    February 9, 2021
    New plan urgently needed to cope with surge in mental health problems
    January 9, 2021
    Covid contract report reveals waste, cronyism and absent process
    December 8, 2020
    COVID drug treatments explained
    November 24, 2020
    More trouble with NHS contracts and outsourcing
    November 21, 2020
    Assisted dying: Where is the UK? New Zealand is the latest country to allow it.
    November 8, 2020
    Previous Next
  • Last 100 articles
  • Campaigns
    1. Keep Our NHS Public
    2. Health Campaigns Together
    3. View All
    Previous Next
  • Search for:
Analysis Bureaucracy Commissioning Integrated care Long read NHS Long Term Plan

Checklist or Wishlist

February 20, 2020
Share
Share on Facebook Share on Twitter LinkedIn Email

NHS England has now published an exhausting list of requirements for local provider trusts, CCGs and embryonic “Integrated Care Systems,” (ICSs) setting them on a route march to a bizarre form of “integration”.

The NHS England vision for integrated care is that the NHS be split into three main levels: neighbourhood (30,000-50,000 population), “place” (250,000-500,000) and “system” (1 million to 3 million), with NHS England and NHS Improvement controlling the whole set-up at regional and national level.

To do this they need to effectively disregard (or persuade government to change) the existing legislation – forced through by the Tory-LibDem coalition in the Health and Social Care Act 2012 – which carved England’s NHS up into a market consisting of local commissioners (200+ CCGs) holding the purse strings, and providers (NHS Trusts, Foundation trusts and GPs, private – for-profit and non-profit – and voluntary sector.)

The 2012 legislation abolished the previous wider local structures (100+ Primary Care Trusts) and regional bodies (Strategic Health Authorities): now NHS England is seeking to put together a new version – so without any statutory powers or legal standing, and without any accountability or transparency at local level.

They are driving the mergers of CCGs, with 56 set to disappear in a new round of mergers from April, leaving just 135 (with more mergers planned), and reorganisation of services into 42 Sustainability and Transformation Partnership (STP) areas, which according to NHS Improvement’s chief operation officer are expected to develop into ICSs by April 2021.

The NHS Operation planning and Contracting Guidance 2020/21 is the latest step towards establishing NHS England’s plan: it is only 40 pages long, but densely packed, with each page studded with extra demands on local health bosses.

The common factor running through all the demands on local commissioners and providers is NHS England’s determination to force them into “Integrated Care Systems” – despite the absence of any legal powers or legitimacy for such bodies to be established, and therefore little if any public accountability for their actions.

No public involvement

There is no mention of public involvement, engagement – or indeed of the public at all, except as the recipients of services commissioned and decided by local health systems. Instead the Introduction claims that the NHS has since last year been in a period of “stability” with the limits of its funding now set in law up to 2024:

“The NHS and its partners have used this stability to develop local system-wide strategic plans during 2019 that will put the NHS on a sustainable financial footing whilst expanding and improving the services and care it provides patients and the public.”

This same blinkered approach – ignoring manifest and major problems – means NHS England makes no reference to the changes they want made to the law, which were outlined in the Long Term Plan and spelled out in more detail during last year.

The Guidance gives no indication of any concern at the lack of commitment of the Johnson government to honour its manifesto pledge to pass the necessary legislation to give ICSs legal standing, and to lift the current legal requirement on CCGs to carve local services into a series of contracts to be put out to competitive tender.

It now seems, according to carefully leaked rumours headlined in the Times, Telegraph, Daily Mail and Independent, that the legislation when passed will include new powers for ministers (and of course Johnson’s Downing Street Svengali Dominic Cummings) to give orders to NHS England’s boss, the freshly-knighted Simon Stevens.

The Times reports concerns of health chiefs who fear this could amount to a fresh reorganisation of the NHS. Campaigners will fear it will assert centralised control while not fully repealing the 2012 Health and Social Care Act that entrenched a costly and divisive “market” in health care.

The Planning Guidance indicates NHS England is forging ahead as if they already had their preferred version of a more centralised system in place, and spells out ways in which commissioners and providers in 42 STP areas are increasingly required to work together as a single “system”.

Section 2.1 of the Guidance makes clear that ALL systems are expected to agree five separate arrangements with NHS England’s regional directors which are key to them progressing to ICSs:

  • a leadership model for the system, “including a Sustainability and Transformation Partnership (STP)/ ICS leader with sufficient capacity”….
  • system capabilities “including population health management, service redesign, workforce transformation, and digitisation” ….
  • agreed ways of working across the system in respect of “financial governance and collaboration” …
  • streamlining commissioning arrangements, “including typically one CCG per system”
  • capital and estates plans at a system level… .

These are to ensure ICSs can carry out two “core roles”: system transformation and collective management of system performance (pulling individual trusts into line).

System planning

Section 2.2 of the Guidance is on “system planning”, again focused on ensuring that every commissioner and provider each of the 42 systems is tied in with “local strategic plans” (few of which have yet been published). In other words the plan is to override the existing (limited) local accountability and existing statutory responsibilities of trusts and CCGs.

Section 3 sets out a tough assault course of performance targets which systems are expected to achieve. In Primary Care a tokenistic carrot of £45m of development funding is to be shared between 42 systems, while the stick includes requirements to invest in extra staff (the unfortunately named ARRS scheme (Additional Roles Reimbursement Scheme), extra doctors, delivering reductions in long waits for routine appointments, and “full delivery of online consultation systems” (whether patients want them or not).

Community health services, with little if any extra resource are required to work to deliver “crisis response services within two hours of referral, and reablement care within two days of referral to those patients who are judged to need it” – although no details are published on how far away they are from that target, or where they are supposed to find staff and funding.

On mental health (3.2) the Guidance refers to (but does not reproduce) over a dozen rigorous “deliverables” to improve performance, despite the fact that the 135 CCGs that will exist from April have to share out a measly £135m “Long Term Plan baseline funding to bolster community mental health provision,” and will get back only 40% of the salary costs of the additional trainees they will need to expand IAPT services.

On learning disabilities (3.3) along with a series of vague commitments to “ensure there is the right range of support and care services in the community”, and to “increased use of Personal Health Budgets”, there is a requirement to visit adult inpatients in out of area placements every 8 weeks, and children every 6 weeks – hardly inspiring for those fearful these patients will be largely neglected and forgotten.

On urgent and emergency care (3.4) there is a historic shift away from three decades of  efforts to reduce front line bed numbers:

“systems and organisations will be expected to reduce general and acute bed occupancy levels to a maximum of 92%. This means that the long period of reducing the number of beds across the NHS should not be expected to continue. …

“The default operational assumption is that the peak of open bed capacity achieved through the winter of 2019/20 will be at least maintained through 2020/21, including the 3,000 increase from October 2019 already planned for.”

Credible plans

It appears that the onus is now on those seeking to reduce bed numbers, or increase by a lower amount, to produce “Credible plans to release capacity through reductions in length of stay, improvements in Delayed Transfers of Care (DTOCs), and admission avoidance programmes”.  But we have heard similar before from NHS England, without any let-up in the run-down of bed numbers.

Despite recent warnings on lack of capacity from the Royal College of Emergency Medicine and the Society of Acute Medicine, there is an ambitious target to increase “same day emergency care” by September, and 65% delivering acute frailty services.

And as trusts implement plans to institutionalise it, with corridor nurses and paramedics, NHS England is demanding measures to avoid ambulance delays and “eliminate corridor care”.

“Waiting lists should be lower”

More ambitious still are the demands on elective care (3.5): “Specifically, the waiting list on 31 January 2021 should be lower than that at 31 January 2020. …

“Providers should ensure appropriate planning and profiling of elective and non-elective activity throughout the year, taking into consideration expected peaks in non-elective performance over winter months in order to avoid risk of unplanned cancellations.

“Waits of 52 weeks or more for treatment should be eradicated.”

So easy to say, so hard to do without sufficient beds, staff, capital or revenue. Indeed if it was that easy it would already have been done.

Similarly fanciful demands follow for changes to outpatient services (3.6), reduced waits for cancer treatment (3.7), and an even more unrealistic section on public health (3.8), which simply piles on more tasks and targets without giving any baseline figures on the current state of play, discussing the cuts in funding that have been made, or identifying any additional resources.

The “People” plan (Section 4) continues the theme of wishful thinking, though it does note that the infamous promise of 50,000 extra nurses is to be delivered “by 2025,” (together with 6,000 more doctors working in primary care and a 26,000 increase in the wider primary care workforce).

The credibility of the proposals is not enhanced by the focus on “a significant expansion of ethical international recruitment of high-quality nurses, driven by a new national programme which will be established early in 2020.”

Government erecting barriers

It appears nobody in NHS England has noticed the government’s efforts to deter immigration of anyone earning less than £30,000 a year, and the associated hefty upfront costs of even the discounted NHS visa and the commitment to jack up the annual “Immigration Health Surcharge” to £625 per year.

But then the Planning Guidance appears to be more of a wish list than a check list, not so much blue skies thinking as cloud cuckoo land. Only the strings and financial penalties are real – and the extent to which these can make trusts and commissioners jump through NHS England’s hoops remains to be seen.

Whether any of this can meaningfully be called “integration” is another question.

The test is in the financial discipline. While the HSJ has reported the “unprecedented” decision of the merging CCGs in Norfolk and Waveney to chip in with financial support “to help two acute trusts agree control totals”, The Lowdown waits with interest to see the first trust or foundation trust running a surplus that is willing to part with some or all of it in order to ensure a local system including trusts in deficit can meet its control total.

Dear Reader,

If you like our content please support our campaigning journalism to protect health care for all. 

Our goal is to inform people, hold our politicians to account and help to build change through evidence based ideas.

Everyone should have access to comprehensive healthcare, but our NHS needs support. You can help us to continue to counter bad policy, battle neglect of the NHS and correct dangerous mis-infomation.

Supporters of the NHS are crucial in sustaining our health service and with your help we will be able to engage more people in securing its future.

Please donate to help support our campaigning NHS research and  journalism.                              

DONATE
CCGsdelayed transfers of careintegrated careintegrated care organisationintegrated care systemNHS Englandpublic engagement
0
John Lister
Author John Lister

Related Posts

Operose CEO moves to Number 10 advisor position

April 1, 2021

The History of Privatisation part 4: The early days of PFI

March 29, 2021

Bleak prospects for troubled ICSs

March 21, 2021

Waiting lists during the pandemic: from zero tolerance to looming crisis

March 20, 2021

Private sector unfazed by White Paper

March 6, 2021

Campaigners write to Hancock requesting investigation of Centene takeover of London GP surgeries

February 25, 2021

Comments are closed.

  • Receive out latest content – stay in touch

    • Recent
    • Popular
    • Tags
  • Navigation
    • About us – campaigning journalism on the NHS
    • Support Us
    • Editorial Policy
    • Cookies and Privacy Policy
    • Contact
  • Recent
    • April 1, 2021
      Operose CEO moves to Number 10 advisor position
    • March 31, 2021
      Billions are spent by the NHS on drugs every year, but how does it work?
  • RSS Lowdown RSS
    • Operose CEO moves to Number 10 advisor position
    • Billions are spent by the NHS on drugs every year, but how does it work?
    • The History of Privatisation part 4: The early days of PFI
  • Facebook
  • Twitter

© 2019 Centre for Equitable Healthcare | All rights reserved | Company No: 8162172

Top
The Lowdown

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.

    Privacy & Cookies
    This website uses cookies, we assume you are OK with this, but you can opt-out if you wish. To find out more about how we use cookies and how to manage them, read our privacy and cookie policy. Accept Read More
    Privacy & Cookies Policy

    Privacy Overview

    This website uses cookies to improve your experience while you navigate through the website. Out of these, the cookies that are categorized as necessary are stored on your browser as they are essential for the working of basic functionalities of the website. We also use third-party cookies that help us analyze and understand how you use this website. These cookies will be stored in your browser only with your consent. You also have the option to opt-out of these cookies. But opting out of some of these cookies may affect your browsing experience.
    Necessary
    Always Enabled

    Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.

    Non-necessary

    Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.

    SAVE & ACCEPT