• Health News,
  • Analysis,
  • Campaigns
  • SUPPORT US
  • Facebook
  • X (Twitter)
The Lowdown The Lowdown
  • News
    NHS landlord bought by private equity
    April 15, 2025
    Changing stories as England’s NHS charts course for cuts
    April 8, 2025
    East of England ICBs brace for another year of austerity
    March 28, 2025
    Spring Budget 2025 analysis: What is the outlook for health and social care?
    March 28, 2025
    SubCos return, in threat to NHS pay and conditions
    March 24, 2025
    Previous Next
  • Topics
    1. NHS Long Term Plan
    2. Mental health
    3. Outsourcing
    4. Building a sustainable NHS
    5. Safety
    6. Private Providers
    7. Quality
    8. Hospitals
    9. Community healthcare
    10. Access
    11. NHS@75
    12. View All
    Criticism of the long-term workforce plan begins to emerge
    July 14, 2023
    Will Coffey plan rescue the struggling NHS?
    September 26, 2022
    Why are people objecting to CCG mergers?
    September 28, 2020
    Is Johnson pondering a NHS power grab?
    July 21, 2020
    Children waiting and rejected for mental healthcare
    January 31, 2025
    Funding needed sooner not later: London mental health cuts
    September 15, 2024
    Urgent review of mental health services requested by NHS England
    August 1, 2024
    Leading private mental health provider to the NHS narrowly avoids liquidation
    July 3, 2024
    Waste and delay still occur in improved outsourcing process
    March 17, 2025
    Fresh round of strikes against privatising Colchester services
    September 15, 2024
    NHS privatisation: will Colchester be the last time?
    July 21, 2024
    Secret plan to outsource Colchester services 
    May 27, 2024
    Government retreats from promises and targets
    February 6, 2025
    To get NHS out of this hole – stop digging
    January 19, 2023
    Worst-ever crisis set to get worse
    September 6, 2022
    Warnings for coming winter as NHS capacity reduced
    July 7, 2022
    Survey finds Scottish health staff are too overworked to report problems
    May 25, 2023
    UNISON survey shows leap in concerns over standard of care
    March 15, 2023
    Analysis: policy is a greater threat to patient safety than striking nurses
    December 20, 2022
    GPs call for a Rebuild of General Practice
    March 24, 2022
    Management consultants step up for NHS shakeup and beyond
    March 22, 2025
    Waste and delay still occur in improved outsourcing process
    March 17, 2025
    Lack of accountability and management failure: what the ESNEFT outsourcing decision reveals
    March 6, 2025
    Labour drags NHS ‘back to the future’
    February 21, 2025
    Maternity safety compromised in a third of NHS trusts
    July 9, 2021
    CQC calls for intervention at failing trust
    July 21, 2020
    10 questions to ask about the NHS deal with the private hospitals
    June 23, 2020
    Too few midwives and too little funding continues to affect safe maternity care
    March 18, 2020
    Axing NHS England – a diversion from urgent problems?
    March 21, 2025
    Streeting tries to bury bad news: new hospitals postponed to 2040s
    January 31, 2025
    Doctors warnings ignored as fresh winter crisis looms
    November 5, 2024
    NHS backlog repair bill soars towards £14 billion
    November 5, 2024
    Neighbourhood health care could stretch NHS budget to breaking point
    April 16, 2025
    Push for virtual wards an opportunity for the private sector
    May 4, 2022
    GPs call for a Rebuild of General Practice
    March 24, 2022
    Javid focuses on pharmacies to help GP workload
    October 18, 2021
    Delayed discharge explainer: health and care pressure
    February 24, 2025
    Employers offer more health insurance benefits
    February 9, 2025
    Explainer – Drug shortages
    August 22, 2024
    Emergency departments still struggling to cope with rising demand
    April 17, 2024
    Private equity: the new face of privatisation?
    April 20, 2024
    Why we need more public health services
    February 1, 2024
    10 reasons why sustained NHS funding rises are unavoidable?
    July 5, 2023
    What are the four basic models of healthcare? 
    June 28, 2023
    Delayed discharge explainer: health and care pressure
    February 24, 2025
    Employers offer more health insurance benefits
    February 9, 2025
    Government retreats from promises and targets
    February 6, 2025
    No peace for Streeting as battle over Physician Associates continues
    October 13, 2024
    Previous Next
  • Analysis
    1. Comment
    2. Long read
    3. View All
    What difference has Labour made so far?
    April 28, 2025
    Axing NHS England – a diversion from urgent problems?
    March 21, 2025
    Purge of top management indicates deep NHS cuts to come
    March 16, 2025
    Lack of accountability and management failure: what the ESNEFT outsourcing decision reveals
    March 6, 2025
    Ignore bizarre business advice: use PPUs to treat NHS patients
    August 2, 2024
    ICB financial squeeze set to tighten
    April 25, 2023
    It’s high time ministers and NHS took staffing crisis seriously
    February 6, 2022
    More flaws exposed in ‘integrated care’
    November 14, 2021
    Neighbourhood health care could stretch NHS budget to breaking point
    April 16, 2025
    Two huge community care services outsourced, but with what oversight?
    February 12, 2025
    Employers offer more health insurance benefits
    February 9, 2025
    Can Trump cut health spending?
    February 3, 2025
    Previous Next
  • Explainers
    Review of new report: “forty years of failure” – examining the lessons from NHS outsourcing
    April 4, 2025
    Delayed discharge explainer: health and care pressure
    February 24, 2025
    How can the public scrutinise their ICB?
    February 17, 2025
    Employers offer more health insurance benefits
    February 9, 2025
    Solving the social care problem
    January 13, 2025
    Previous Next
  • Last 100 articles
    • Back issues
  • ICS WATCH
  • Campaigns
    1. Keep Our NHS Public
    2. Health Campaigns Together
    3. View All
    Previous Next
  • Search for:
Accountability Comment Integrated care

ICBs offer no real place for accountability

June 30, 2022
Share
Facebook Twitter LinkedIn Email

Comment by writer and campaigner John Lister


One of the stock, unconvincing answers to those who have challenged the lack of local accountability in the new system of 42 “Integrated Care Systems” (ICSs) that will take over control of England’s NHS at the start of July has been to claim that many decisions in the larger ICS areas would be taken at more localised “place” level.

This has been a key factor in winning endorsement from the Local Government Association for a system that in reality keeps the NHS firmly in charge, but makes use of  local councils to give a spurious veneer of more democratic and local involvement.

Exactly how much difference, if any, place-based organisation might make – especially when the dominant pressure is the financial constraints on ICSs and requirement to eliminate deficits, and with no place-level decision-making body, no public representation, little or no public access to the executive lead, and minimal, if any, information on potentially controversial issues in local news media – has not been explained.

But too many it will look like a sham.

As the new system, which has been put in place with the barest minimum of pretence of public involvement or consultation, sits on the launch-pad, a June 23 report by the Health Service Journal, based on research in May and June, has revealed that half of the ICBs have not even appointed the bureaucrats to lead the “places,” which are not expected to be functional until the autumn.

The HSJ calculates 39 of the 42 ICSs between them are set to establish 175 “places,” while three single-county ICSs (Gloucestershire, Lincolnshire and Somerset) have decided not to establish any more local bodies.

Each ‘place’ is supposed to have a single leader, accountable to the newly-established Integrated Care Boards (ICBs). But only 16 ICBs have chosen “some or all” of these executive leads. Of those who have been appointed:  “The majority are CCG/ICB executives or local council executives, with a significant minority being NHS provider chief executives.”

Supporters of the changes have also argued that, in line with the letter of the Health and Care Act, ICBs which will have the full statutory powers and control of budgets will also have to “have regard to” the local strategy drawn up by broader Integrated Care Partnerships, (ICPs) which are supposed to link up the NHS with local government and other “partners”.

But the HSJ reveals only 21 of the 42 ICSs have so far even appointed their ICP chair: nine of these turn out to be also the ICB chair, underlining a complete lack of any independence of the ICP. Most of the rest are councillors.

So even before the new system creaks into gear it’s already embarrassingly obvious that the ICPs, non-statutory bodies with only the most tenuous and theoretical role or influence, and created as a sop to appease local Tory councillors, are a marginal, irrelevant appendage to each ICB that nobody will take seriously.

As we have consistently warned in The Lowdown, the new system of ICSs/ICBs marks a major further erosion of local public accountability, and the challenge for campaigners will be to keep track of changes and policies as they take shape at ICB level.

Meanwhile the Health Foundation has published a useful new study highlighting the huge variation between ICBs. It shows the range of population covered – between 500,000 and 3.1m; the varying levels of deprivation; the varying levels of potentially avoidable use of emergency and hospital care; the elective care backlog;  and the near 50% variation in provision of GPs – which once again confirms the famous “inverse care law” highlighted in 1970 by Dr Julian Tudor Hart, noting that the areas with the greatest levels of deprivation consistently also had the fewest GPs per head of population, while the wealthier, healthier populations were far better provided. Even now NHS England is still only talking about this issue rather than taking any action.

Over 50 years on, with inequalities in health and in living standards widened by a decade and more of cynical government policy, a new “inverse rhetoric law” brings us more empty government words about “levelling up” the wider the gap becomes between richest and poorest.

Integrated Care Systems, established in a new wave of austerity, with Health Secretary Sajid Javid insisting that the NHS does not need and should not receive any more funding, will resolve none of this: nor indeed can ICSs address the parallel, hopeless privatised shambles of social care. And without functioning social care, the NHS cannot hope to free up the flow of patients through the hospital system.

As the new ‘reformed’ system launches as a half-arsed, chaotic, cash starved mess, under a smokescreen of unreadable and empty rhetoric, it’s up to campaigners, the unions, any local politicians who really care about their constituents and any NHS managers with a shred of self-respect to fight to expose the contradictions and gaps, challenge the short-sighted cutbacks and panic measures that are likely to follow in the autumn, and try to defend the services we all depend upon.

 

Dear Reader,

If you like our content please support our campaigning journalism to protect health care for all. 

Our goal is to inform people, hold our politicians to account and help to build change through evidence based ideas.

Everyone should have access to comprehensive healthcare, but our NHS needs support. You can help us to continue to counter bad policy, battle neglect of the NHS and correct dangerous mis-infomation.

Supporters of the NHS are crucial in sustaining our health service and with your help we will be able to engage more people in securing its future.

Please donate to help support our campaigning NHS research and  journalism.                              

DONATE
accountabilityhealth foundationICBicsintegrated care partnershipintegrated care systemspublic engagement
0
Author John Lister

Related Posts

What difference has Labour made so far?

April 28, 2025

Management consultants step up for NHS shakeup and beyond

March 22, 2025

Axing NHS England – a diversion from urgent problems?

March 21, 2025

Purge of top management indicates deep NHS cuts to come

March 16, 2025

Lack of accountability and management failure: what the ESNEFT outsourcing decision reveals

March 6, 2025

Labour drags NHS ‘back to the future’

February 21, 2025
  • Receive out latest content



    • Recent
    • Popular
    • Tags
  • Navigation
    • About us – campaigning journalism on the NHS
    • Support Us
    • Editorial Policy
    • Cookies and Privacy Policy
    • Contact
  • Recent
    • April 28, 2025

      What difference has Labour made so far?

    • April 16, 2025

      Neighbourhood health care could stretch NHS budget to breaking point

  • Facebook
  • X (Twitter)

© 2022 Centre for Equitable Healthcare | All rights reserved | Company No: 8162172

Top
The Lowdown

    Type above and press Enter to search. Press Esc to cancel.