Private providers that have been awarded NHS contracts come from the whole spectrum of funding models for organisations:
- Not-for-profit/community enterprises
- Private not owned by shareholders
- Private limited companies owned by shareholders
- Companies listed on the stock exchange
These organisations are funded in very different ways. Charities and community enterprises rely on money from grants, donations and contract work, whereas private companies are reliant on investment from individuals, investments funds and banks as well as profit from contract work.
All of these categories of organisation, regardless of size, can get into financial difficulties and no type of organisation is immune to financial meltdown. When this happens, the NHS and councils are left to pick up the pieces, often at short notice and with more expense.
This was shown very clearly in 2018 with the collapse of the the global FTSE 100 company Carillion. The company had contracts with the NHS for building hospitals and services. In May 2018, a parliamentary report noted that Carillion’s business model was a “relentless dash for cash, driven by acquisitions, rising debt, expansion into new markets and exploitation of suppliers”. The company’s business was enabled by dodgy accounts and greedy executives. At the end, Carillion had £16bn of government contracts. The Carillion collapse resulted in 2,000 lost jobs and 27,000 current and former employees will get smaller pensions; and £150m of government cash is needed to prop up essential contracts.
2018 also saw financial difficulties for one of the UK’s largest home care supplier, Allied Healthcare. In October 2018, the CQC issued a report on the financial status of Allied Healthcare; Allied Healthcare was due to make a large loan repayment at the end of November 2018 but there appeared to be insufficient funds. The report noted that the company might not continue trading after the end of November 2018. A letter to all councils and CCGs advised them to make contingency arrangements in the event of the company withdrawing from contracts.
Allied Healthcare provides care and support to over 13,000 elderly and disabled people in their homes. The company’s Primecare subsidiary has contracts for out-of-hours and urgent care throughout the midlands. In Birmingham, Primecare gave GP practices just 10 days notice to seek replacement OOH cover. Primecare also provides OOH and urgent care services in Walsall, Sandwell and West Birmingham, Herefordshire, and Nene, and is part of an integrated 111 and OOH contract covering 16 CCGs in the west Midlands. All these areas have had to find replacement providers. Allied Healthcare is owned by German private equity investor Aurelius.
The long-term care sector is in a particularly difficult financial position, with leading providers such as Four Seasons reported to be in a precarious financial position: for more details see our Long-Term Care Sector.
Financial difficulties played a role in the disastrous Coperforma contract for non-emergency transport in Sussex and a number of other private ambulance companies have ceased trading over the years following financial difficulties, leaving NHS organisations to pick up the pieces, often at short notice. Details can be found in the section – Contract failures in the ambulance service.
In the primary care sector, several companies have closed GP surgeries due to financial difficulties, including Danum Medical Services in Doncaster and Horizon Health Choices Ltd in Bedfordshire. More details can be found in the section – Contract failures in GP services.
In the private hospital market, many of the companies have found themselves in difficult financial situations over recent years. One reason is costly rent agreements that were signed before the 2008 financial crisis, which made businesses vulnerable to a fixed annual increase in rents. In October 2018, Reuters reported on the private hospital chain BMI Healthcare finally agreeing a financial restructuring deal with its landlords and creditors.
See further reading below for more information on financial insecurity.
If you like our content please support our campaigning journalism to protect health care for all.
Our goal is to inform people, hold our politicians to account and help to build change through evidence based ideas.
Everyone should have access to comprehensive healthcare, but our NHS needs support. You can help us to continue to counter bad policy, battle neglect of the NHS and correct dangerous mis-infomation.
Supporters of the NHS are crucial in sustaining our health service and with your help we will be able to engage more people in securing its future.
Please donate to help support our campaigning NHS research and journalism.